Misleading Headlines, Poorly Written English: Why Are We Still Seeing This in the Age of AI?


From misleading headlines to poorly written articles, has the rush for online attention come at the expense of good communication?
We live in an age where information is available almost instantly. Whether it is breaking news, entertainment updates, business developments or simply something happening halfway across the world, chances are we will come across it on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok or another social media platform before we even think about visiting an actual news website.
And with so many digital publishers, independent content creators and social media news pages competing for our attention, the way information is presented has changed considerably.
Headlines have become more dramatic. Captions are written to encourage reactions. Articles are sometimes structured to keep readers scrolling rather than to help them understand what actually happened.
There is nothing inherently wrong with wanting people to read your content. After all, attracting attention is part of communication, and from a marketing perspective, a well written headline can make all the difference between someone scrolling past or stopping to read.
But somewhere along the way, I cannot help wondering whether we have become so focused on getting that initial click that we have forgotten the importance of what comes after it.
And then there is another issue altogether. The English.
When the Headline Tells One Story and the Article Tells Another
I am sure many of us have experienced this.
You come across a headline that sounds rather alarming, controversial or interesting enough to make you curious. Perhaps it suggests that a company is shutting down, a celebrity has made a shocking announcement or a particular incident has taken an unexpected turn.
Naturally, you click on it because you want to know more.
Only to discover that the actual article tells a completely different story.
Perhaps the company is merely closing one outlet rather than shutting down entirely.
Perhaps the celebrity's statement was taken out of context. Or perhaps the incident was not nearly as dramatic as the headline made it sound.
Technically, the headline might not be entirely false. But the way it was written deliberately encouraged readers to form an impression that the article itself does not support.
This is where I think we need to distinguish between an attention grabbing headline and a misleading one.
In marketing, we understand the importance of a hook. Whether it is an advertisement, a social media caption, an email subject line or a blog title, the opening needs to capture someone's interest.
However, a good hook should create curiosity without distorting the message.
If the headline promises something that the content does not deliver, it might generate traffic in the short term, but what happens to the reader's trust in the long run? And if that same publisher repeatedly uses this approach, would readers eventually stop taking its content seriously?
Perhaps not immediately.
After all, curiosity is a powerful thing but I would argue that repeatedly disappointing readers is hardly a sustainable content strategy.
The Other Problem: When the English Barely Makes Sense
Misleading headlines are one issue. Poorly written English is another, and sometimes I find the latter even more frustrating.
I am not referring to the occasional spelling mistake, misplaced comma or grammatical error. Those happen to everyone, including people who write professionally. Neither am I suggesting that everyone needs to write in perfect British or American English. Language is influenced by culture, background and personal expression. In Singapore, for instance, we have our own way of communicating, and there are situations where Singlish makes a message feel more relatable and authentic.
What I am referring to is content that is so poorly constructed that readers have to go through the same sentence several times just to figure out what the writer is trying to say.
There are articles with sentences that do not connect logically, headlines that seem to be missing important words, and paragraphs where the grammar is so confusing that the intended meaning becomes almost impossible to understand.
Sometimes, it even feels as though the content has been translated directly from another language without anyone checking whether the English version makes sense. And these are not always casual posts written by individuals sharing their personal experiences. Some come from pages that position themselves as news sources, information platforms or professional publications.
Which makes me wonder: if the purpose of publishing an article is to communicate information, should making that information understandable not be the most basic requirement?
Readers should be spending their time understanding the story, not trying to decipher the sentence.
We Have AI Writing Tools Now. So Why Not Use Them Properly?
This is perhaps the part that puzzles me the most.
We are no longer living in a time when improving written content necessarily requires hiring a professional editor for every single article.
Today, we have tools such as ChatGPT, Claude and other AI writing assistants that can help identify grammatical errors, improve sentence structure, suggest clearer phrasing and make content easier to understand. And yet, poorly written articles continue to appear across social media and digital publishing platforms.
Of course, not everyone wants to use artificial intelligence to create content. There are valid concerns about originality, authenticity and the tendency for AI generated writing to sound overly polished or generic.
I understand that.
In fact, I personally do not think every piece of content should be written entirely by AI.
There is a difference between allowing AI to write your thoughts for you and using AI to help you express those thoughts more clearly.
For example, if someone has written an article based on their own research, opinions or reporting, why not use an AI tool to review the grammar and sentence structure before publishing it?
The instruction can be as simple as:
"Please check the grammar, spelling and sentence structure of this article. Keep my original tone and writing style. Do not change the meaning, introduce new information or make it sound overly formal or AI generated."
That is all.
The writer remains responsible for the ideas, facts and message. The technology simply assists with the presentation.
To me, that is a far more sensible use of AI than asking it to generate an entire article without understanding or reviewing what it produces. Of course, AI tools are not perfect either. They can misunderstand context, change the intended meaning or confidently introduce inaccurate information. That is why the final responsibility must always remain with the person publishing the content.
But when used as an editing assistant rather than a replacement for human thinking, surely there is value in having an additional layer of review?
Not Everything Needs to Sound Like It Was Written by AI
There is also a growing perception that AI assisted writing has a particular style.
We have probably seen it. Articles filled with elaborate introductions, unnecessarily dramatic statements, repetitive explanations and phrases that sound impressive but do not actually say very much.
Sometimes, the writing is grammatically correct, yet the personality behind it seems to have disappeared.
This is not what good writing should become. A person can write casually, professionally, humorously or conversationally while still using proper grammar and clear sentence structures. The objective should not be to make every article sound sophisticated. It should be to make the intended message understandable.
And that is something I feel many people misunderstand about using AI for content creation.
Just because a tool can rewrite an entire article does not mean we should allow it to.
Sometimes, the best use of technology is simply to correct what needs correcting and leave everything else alone.
A writer's personality, perspective and choice of expression are what make the content worth reading in the first place.
If every article begins to sound the same, we might solve the problem of poor grammar only to create another problem: content without individuality.
From a Marketing Perspective, Every Headline Is a Promise
When I look at this from a marketing strategist's perspective, I see a bigger issue than simply whether an article is well written. I see a problem with the relationship between content, audience expectations and brand credibility.
Every headline creates an expectation.
When someone clicks on an article, they are essentially responding to the promise made by that headline. They expect the content to provide the information, explanation or perspective that initially attracted their attention.
This is not very different from advertising.
Imagine seeing an advertisement promoting a particular offer, only to discover upon visiting the website that the actual terms are completely different from what the advertisement suggested.
You might still explore the website, but would you feel misled?
The same principle applies to editorial content.
A misleading headline might generate a higher click through rate, but that number alone does not tell us whether the content was successful.
Did readers find what they were looking for?
Did they understand the information?
Did they consider the publisher credible?
Would they return to the same source again?
These are equally important questions.
In digital marketing, we often talk about impressions, reach, engagement, clicks and conversions. These metrics help us understand how content performs, but they do not always tell the complete story.
A high number of clicks does not automatically indicate quality content, just as a high number of reactions does not necessarily mean readers trust what they have seen. And when an article is poorly written, the problem becomes even more obvious. If readers cannot understand the message, how can the content effectively inform, persuade or build confidence?
Search Visibility Is Important, but So Is the Reader's Experience
There is another dimension to consider, particularly for businesses and digital publishers that rely on organic traffic.
Search engine optimisation, or SEO, has long influenced how articles are structured and presented online. Headlines are written around search terms. Subheadings are organised to make content easier to navigate. Keywords are incorporated to help search engines understand what a page is about.
These practices are useful when applied appropriately.
But SEO should not become an excuse to produce awkward, repetitive or unnatural writing simply because someone believes certain phrases need to appear multiple times.
Search visibility and readability should complement each other.
A well structured article with a clear headline, relevant information and natural language can serve both readers and search engines without sacrificing the quality of the writing.
The same consideration is becoming increasingly relevant as people use AI powered search tools to discover and understand information.
Being discoverable is important, but the information itself must still be accurate, coherent and useful. There is little value in attracting someone to an article if the experience leaves them confused or questioning the reliability of the source.
The Responsibility Still Belongs to the Person Publishing
Perhaps the most important point in all of this is that technology does not remove the responsibility of the writer, editor or publisher.
Whether an article is written entirely by a person, translated from another language or edited with AI assistance, someone still needs to review it before it goes online.
Does the headline accurately reflect the story? Are the facts correct? Is the sentence structure clear? Could the wording be misunderstood? Has the original meaning been preserved?
These are not particularly complicated questions, but they can make a significant difference to the quality of the final content.
For established news organisations, editorial standards and fact checking should already be part of the publishing process. For smaller publishers, independent writers and social media content creators, the resources may be more limited. But that is precisely where accessible writing tools can be helpful.
I do not expect every publisher to have an entire editorial team. I do, however, think it is reasonable to expect anyone presenting information to the public to make an effort to communicate it clearly.
Especially when the tools to assist with that process are now more accessible than ever.
Good Writing Is Not About Perfect English. It Is About Clear Communication.
At the end of the day, I do not believe the solution is to make everyone write like a professional journalist, nor do I think AI should become the default author of everything we read online.
People have different writing abilities, language backgrounds and ways of expressing themselves. That diversity should not disappear simply because technology can produce grammatically polished sentences.
But there is a difference between having a unique writing style and publishing something that readers struggle to understand. There is also a difference between creating an interesting headline and deliberately presenting a story in a way that gives readers the wrong impression.
As someone working in marketing, I appreciate the importance of attracting attention. I understand why publishers compete for clicks, why headlines are carefully crafted and why content needs to stand out in an increasingly crowded digital environment.
But I also believe that attention should never come at the expense of clarity and credibility.
We have spent years developing tools that make content creation faster, easier and more accessible. Perhaps it is time we paid just as much attention to whether the content we publish is actually worth reading.
Because a headline may convince someone to click once.
But it is the quality, accuracy and clarity of the content that gives them a reason to trust you enough to return.
Written from the perspective of Trixy.&, where marketing is not simply about being seen, but about communicating with purpose and building meaningful connections with an audience.




Comments