top of page
trixy.& logo top.png

Are Online Marketplaces Helping Businesses Grow or Making Them Too Dependent?

Writer: Trixy Gabriela Tan
Trixy Gabriela Tan
Nov 10
16 min read

The evolution of online shopping, changing consumer expectations and why businesses need to think beyond simply being where everyone else is selling.


Remember the days when Yahoo Auctions was one of the places to buy and sell things online? Long before Shopee and Lazada became household names in Singapore, people were already discovering the convenience of browsing listings, comparing prices and purchasing items from strangers over the internet.


Then came platforms such as eBay and Amazon, which became major names in international ecommerce. Closer to home, Qoo10 gained popularity among Singapore shoppers before Shopee and Lazada eventually became two of the most recognisable online shopping platforms in the region.


Meanwhile, China's ecommerce ecosystem was developing at an incredible pace. Taobao introduced many shoppers to an enormous selection of products at competitive prices. AliExpress brought Chinese merchants closer to international consumers, although it never quite achieved the same mainstream presence in Singapore as Shopee or Lazada. More recently, Pinduoduo and its internationally focused sister platform, Temu, have attracted attention through aggressive pricing, promotions and shopping experiences designed to encourage repeat purchases.


Today, consumers are surrounded by more online shopping options than ever before. Some platforms focus on convenience, others on affordability, product discovery or the excitement of finding a bargain.


But while consumers are enjoying the variety, businesses are facing an increasingly complicated question.



Should they sell through online marketplaces, invest in their own ecommerce websites, or maintain a presence on both?


At first glance, the answer seems obvious. Why not be everywhere and reach as many potential customers as possible?


However, from a marketing strategy perspective, having more selling channels does not automatically translate into better business performance. There are costs, customer behaviours and long term implications that businesses need to understand before deciding where to invest their resources.



How Online Marketplaces Changed the Way We Shop


In the earlier days of online shopping, purchasing something over the internet required a certain level of trust and patience. Buyers had to communicate with sellers, arrange payments and sometimes wait without the tracking information or buyer protection mechanisms that we have become accustomed to today.


Modern marketplaces have removed much of that uncertainty.


Consumers can now browse thousands of products, read customer reviews, compare prices, apply vouchers, select delivery options and complete their purchases without leaving a single application. More importantly, these platforms have gradually changed what customers expect from online shopping. A product being available online is no longer enough. Consumers increasingly expect competitive prices, convenient payment methods, reliable delivery and some form of promotional benefit.


For example, someone shopping for a household appliance may find the same model listed on a company's official website, Shopee and Lazada. The product itself may be identical, but the purchasing experience can be very different.


On a marketplace, the customer might receive a platform voucher, enjoy free shipping subject to a minimum spend, earn reward points or have access to an instalment payment option. On the company's website, the product might be sold at its regular retail price with fewer promotional incentives or payment choices.


Even if the customer trusts the brand, why would they necessarily purchase directly from the website when another platform appears to offer better value? This is where the difference between consumer behaviour and business strategy becomes particularly interesting.



Why Consumers Are Drawn to Online Marketplaces


Price is often the first reason that comes to mind, but it is certainly not the only one.


One of the biggest advantages marketplaces have created is convenience. Consumers no longer need to visit multiple websites, register separate accounts or repeatedly enter their payment and delivery information. Everything is centralised within an application they already use.


The ability to compare products also plays an important role. Instead of relying entirely on a brand's own product descriptions, customers can evaluate competing products, read reviews and see photographs uploaded by previous buyers. Although reviews are not always reliable, they provide an additional layer of reassurance that an individual company website may struggle to replicate.


Then there are the promotional mechanics.


Monthly payday sales, double digit shopping campaigns such as 11.11 and 12.12, platform vouchers, shipping subsidies, coins and payment promotions have turned online shopping into something more than a straightforward transaction.


For some consumers, purchasing an item at the right promotional period becomes part of the experience. Payment flexibility has also become an important consideration. Depending on the platform, payment provider and eligibility, shoppers may be able to split purchases into monthly payments without using a traditional credit card instalment plan. However, these arrangements are not always interest free or fee free, and late payment charges or other conditions may apply.


For higher value purchases, the availability of such payment options can influence whether a customer completes a transaction or postpones it.


A business might have an excellent product and a beautifully designed website, but if its checkout experience does not accommodate how its customers prefer to pay, it may still lose the sale.


Consumers are not always choosing the cheapest product. They are choosing the purchasing experience that offers them the greatest perceived value.

The lesson here is simple.



Why Businesses Are Flocking to Marketplaces


From a business owner's perspective, online marketplaces offer something extremely attractive: access to an existing pool of potential customers.


Building an ecommerce website requires an investment in design, product management, payment integration, security, maintenance and marketing. Even after launching the website, the business still needs to attract visitors.


A website does not automatically generate sales simply because it exists.


Marketplaces, on the other hand, already have consumers actively browsing and searching for products. A business can create a seller account, upload product listings and potentially begin reaching customers without first developing a standalone e-commerce website.


This significantly reduces the technical barriers to entering e-commerce, although seller fees, operational requirements and marketing expenses still apply.


Beyond convenience, there are several strategic advantages.



Product Discovery and Brand Exposure


A customer may not know that a particular brand exists, but they might discover its products while searching for something similar on Shopee or Lazada. This is especially valuable for smaller businesses that do not have the advertising budgets or brand recognition of established competitors.


Marketplaces effectively act as additional product discovery channels, placing businesses in front of consumers who already demonstrate purchasing intent.

However, visibility is not guaranteed. Search rankings, advertising placements, seller performance, pricing and customer reviews can all influence whether a product is discovered.



Building Consumer Confidence


For unfamiliar brands, the credibility associated with an established marketplace can reduce hesitation.


Customers may feel more comfortable purchasing through a platform that provides structured payment processes, delivery tracking and dispute resolution mechanisms. This does not mean that every seller or transaction is trustworthy. It simply means the platform's established purchasing environment may help overcome some of the uncertainty associated with buying from an unfamiliar business.



Access to Promotional Campaigns


Major shopping campaigns can generate substantial consumer interest within a relatively short period. For participating sellers, these campaigns may create opportunities to introduce new products, clear selected inventory or reach customers who would not otherwise encounter their brands. However, the additional sales need to be assessed against promotional discounts, advertising expenses and any campaign participation costs.


A successful campaign should not be measured by order volume alone.


Testing Product Demand


Marketplaces can also provide a useful environment for testing new products.


Instead of committing immediately to a full ecommerce website, a business can introduce a smaller product range, observe customer response, evaluate pricing and identify which items attract the strongest demand.

This information can support future decisions about product development, inventory planning and marketing investment.


Nevertheless, marketplace performance should not be treated as a complete representation of the wider market. A product that performs well among price sensitive marketplace shoppers may attract a different response through a premium retail environment.



The Hidden Cost of Selling Where Everyone Else Is Selling


While marketplaces can help businesses generate sales, they also introduce costs that are sometimes underestimated.


Depending on the platform, seller category and programme participation, businesses may face commissions, transaction fees, service fees, advertising expenses, promotional contributions and other charges. These expenses can reduce profitability, particularly for businesses operating on already narrow margins.


Consider a hypothetical example: A company sells a product for S$100. Its product cost is S$55, leaving S$45 before other operating expenses. If the combined marketplace fees, advertising and promotional costs amount to S$20, the business is left with S$25 before accounting for other overheads, returns and fulfilment expenses.


The marketplace may have helped secure the sale, but it has also absorbed a meaningful portion of the available margin. The important question is whether the marketplace generated a sale that the business would otherwise not have received. If it did, the additional expense might be justified.


But if an existing customer who would have purchased directly from the company instead uses a marketplace voucher, the business may simply be paying additional fees for a sale it could already have secured.


This is known as channel cannibalisation, where sales through one channel replace rather than genuinely increase sales through another.


Businesses therefore need to distinguish between additional revenue and revenue that has merely shifted between channels.



Marketplace Customers Are Not Necessarily Your Customers


One of the most overlooked differences between selling through a marketplace and operating an independent e-commerce website is customer ownership.


When a customer purchases through a marketplace, the platform largely controls the shopping environment, customer communication and access to transaction data. Businesses may receive the information necessary to process orders and provide customer service, but they generally do not have unrestricted access to customer relationships or the freedom to use that information for independent marketing.


Marketplace policies and data protection requirements can also limit how sellers communicate with buyers outside the platform.

This creates an interesting situation.


A customer might purchase from the same seller several times without ever remembering the business name. Ask them where they bought the item, and the answer may simply be, "I bought it from Shopee."


Not the brand.

Not the company.

Just the platform.


From a marketing perspective, this is a significant distinction.


The marketplace may be generating transactions, but the platform itself is often receiving much of the customer loyalty and habitual engagement. If a competitor offers a similar product at a lower price, there may be very little preventing the customer from switching.


This is particularly challenging for businesses selling products that are easily comparable or available from multiple suppliers.



What an Independent Ecommerce Website Offers That Marketplaces Cannot Fully Replace


An independent e-commerce website serves a different strategic purpose.


It is not simply another location where customers can add products to a shopping cart.

It is a digital environment where a business has greater control over how its brand is presented, how customers experience its products and how long term relationships are developed.



Greater Control Over Brand Identity


On a marketplace, product listings generally follow a standardised layout.


Businesses can upload images, descriptions and branding elements, but the overall shopping experience remains largely controlled by the platform.


An independent website offers greater flexibility.


A furniture company, for example, can showcase its collections through carefully styled interiors, explain the origins of its materials, highlight craftsmanship and demonstrate customisation possibilities.


A skincare brand can explain product ingredients, educate customers about suitable routines and build a stronger emotional connection through storytelling.


These experiences help communicate value beyond price.

This is especially important for businesses whose products require explanation, personalisation or a higher level of customer confidence before purchase.



Stronger Customer Relationships


With an independent website, businesses can build their own customer database through consent based registrations, purchases, enquiries and marketing subscriptions. This creates opportunities for customer retention strategies such as email marketing, personalised recommendations, loyalty programmes and post purchase communication.


Of course, having a customer database does not automatically mean a business can market to everyone freely. Appropriate consent and compliance with applicable data protection requirements remain essential.


The difference is that the business has greater ability to develop a direct and continuing relationship with its customers.



More Control Over the Customer Journey


A marketplace determines much of how customers browse, compare and purchase products.

An independent website allows businesses to design a customer journey around their specific products and audiences.


For example, a company selling customised furniture may want customers to explore different materials, submit measurements, request quotations or arrange consultations before making a purchase.


Such a process may not fit naturally within a standard marketplace listing.


A website can also integrate educational content, customer testimonials, FAQs, after sales support and other resources that contribute to a more complete buying experience.



Long Term Search Visibility


A properly structured website can build visibility through search engine optimisation, commonly known as SEO.


When potential customers search for products, services or related information on Google, relevant website pages may appear in organic search results. Unlike marketplace listings, which compete within a platform's search environment, an independent website allows a business to develop its own content strategy around the topics and search terms relevant to its customers.


This can include product guides, comparisons, educational articles, FAQs and other useful resources.


SEO takes time and ongoing effort, and rankings are never guaranteed.

Nevertheless, the content and website infrastructure remain assets that the business controls and this creates an opportunity to attract customers before they have even decided which product or brand to purchase.



But Having Your Own Website Is Not Automatically Better


It would be misleading to suggest that every business should immediately invest in an independent ecommerce website.


A website comes with its own responsibilities and expenses. Businesses need to consider hosting, payment processing, website maintenance, security, product updates, customer support and ongoing marketing. More importantly, they need a realistic plan for generating traffic. A business could spend thousands of dollars developing a beautiful ecommerce website only to discover that very few people are visiting it.


Meanwhile, its marketplace store may be generating regular orders because consumers are already searching for products there; where this does not necessarily mean the website has failed. It may simply mean that the two channels are performing different functions.


A marketplace can be effective at capturing existing demand, while a website can support brand development, customer education and long term relationship building.


The mistake is expecting both channels to deliver identical results.



Are Businesses That Refuse to Join Marketplaces Losing Out?


Not necessarily.


Some businesses deliberately avoid online marketplaces because the commercial arrangements do not suit their operating models.


For example, a company selling premium or highly specialised products may prefer to maintain tighter control over pricing, customer experience and brand positioning.

Others may have concerns about platform fees, discount expectations, unauthorised resellers or the operational demands of managing additional sales channels.


A business with strong existing customer relationships and consistent direct sales may not need marketplace exposure to achieve its objectives.


In fact, participating in aggressive promotional campaigns could potentially weaken its pricing strategy if customers become accustomed to waiting for discounts. However, choosing not to participate should be a strategic decision rather than a reaction to marketplace fees alone.

A business that dismisses Shopee or Lazada simply because of commission charges may overlook the value of reaching customers who would otherwise never discover its products. The more relevant questions are whether those customers are commercially attractive, whether the business can serve them profitably and whether the platform supports its wider brand objectives.


There is also the question of competition.


If consumers are actively searching for a product category on marketplaces and a business has no presence there, competitors may capture that demand instead and does not automatically mean the business is losing sales. Some customers may still prefer purchasing directly, particularly when they value specialist advice, customisation or after sales support.

But without understanding where its target audience shops, the business is making assumptions rather than informed decisions.


Not every business needs to be on every marketplace. But every business should understand why it has chosen to participate or stay away.



The Risk of Becoming Too Dependent on a Platform


One of the biggest strategic concerns with marketplace selling is dependency.


Imagine a business that generates 80% of its online revenue through a single marketplace.

Over time, it invests in sponsored listings, promotional campaigns and operational processes designed around that platform. Then the marketplace changes its fee structure, search algorithm, seller requirements or promotional policies. Suddenly, the business may find itself paying more to maintain the same level of visibility or experiencing lower sales despite having made no significant changes to its products.


This is not unique to e- commerce marketplaces.


Businesses that rely heavily on social media platforms face similar challenges when algorithms change or organic reach declines. The underlying issue is the same: when a business depends on an external platform to reach its customers, it also becomes exposed to decisions beyond its control.



Thus, channel diversification should be considered part of business risk management, rather than simply an attempt to increase online visibility.

An independent website does not eliminate all risks. Search engine algorithms, advertising costs, technology providers and payment services can still affect performance.

However, having multiple channels can reduce the impact of relying too heavily on any single source of sales.



Why the Cheapest Channel Is Not Always the Most Profitable


One common misconception is that selling directly through a website must always be more profitable because there are no marketplace commissions.


That is not necessarily true.


A direct sale may avoid certain platform fees, but the business might have spent money on Google Ads, Meta advertising, influencer collaborations or other marketing activities to attract that customer. It may also incur payment processing charges, fulfilment costs and customer service expenses.


For example, a business could pay S$15 in marketplace related expenses to secure a S$100 order. Alternatively, it might spend S$25 in advertising to generate the same order through its own website.


In that particular situation, the marketplace could actually be the more economical acquisition channel. However, the calculation changes when repeat purchases are considered. If a customer who purchases through the website subsequently returns several times through direct visits or email marketing, the business may generate additional revenue without paying the same acquisition cost for every transaction.


This is where customer lifetime value becomes important.

Rather than focusing solely on the profitability of an individual order, businesses should consider the total value a customer may generate throughout their relationship with the brand.


A marketplace might provide a lower cost route to acquiring a new customer today, while a direct website may create stronger opportunities for profitable repeat business over time.

Neither outcome is guaranteed.


The right approach depends on actual customer behaviour, acquisition costs, margins and retention performance.



So, Should Businesses Sell on Both Marketplaces and Their Own Websites?


For many businesses, a combination of both channels may offer the greatest strategic flexibility. However, the objective should not be to duplicate every product, promotion and marketing activity across all available platforms.


Each channel should have a clearly defined role.


A marketplace could be used to introduce selected products, reach new audiences and capture consumers who prefer purchasing through established shopping applications.


An independent website could serve as the central brand destination, providing comprehensive product information, customer support, educational content and opportunities to build stronger relationships with customers beyond their initial purchases.


For example, a furniture retailer might use Shopee or Lazada to sell ready made products while directing its broader brand strategy towards an independent website that showcases its full collections, customisation services and craftsmanship.


Similarly, a beauty brand could introduce selected products through marketplaces while using its own website to provide skincare education, personalised recommendations and exclusive product collections.


The key is understanding that different platforms attract consumers with different purchasing intentions.

Someone browsing Shopee during an 11.11 sale may be primarily interested in finding a bargain. Another person searching Google for a specific product or solution may be more interested in quality, suitability and the reputation of the company.


Both are potential customers, but their expectations and purchasing motivations may be different.


Businesses should therefore avoid treating every online channel as an identical sales outlet. Instead, each channel should contribute towards a wider marketing strategy with clearly defined objectives.


Of course, businesses must also respect marketplace policies when promoting their independent websites. Not every platform permits sellers to redirect customers towards external purchasing channels, and attempting to bypass platform rules could create unnecessary risks.



What Businesses Should Really Be Measuring


One of the biggest mistakes businesses make is evaluating their online sales performance based purely on revenue.


A marketplace store generating S$20,000 in monthly sales may appear more successful than an independent website generating S$10,000.


But what happens when we examine the actual costs involved? The marketplace might require higher promotional discounts, advertising expenditure and platform fees.


Meanwhile, the website could be attracting repeat customers who purchase at regular prices with lower marketing costs.


Alternatively, the marketplace might be delivering significantly more profitable orders because the company's website requires expensive advertising campaigns to generate traffic.


Without understanding the numbers, neither channel can automatically be considered better. Businesses should be examining their profitability after selling and marketing expenses, customer acquisition costs, repeat purchase behaviour, average order value and the contribution each channel makes towards overall business growth.


They should also consider how much time and manpower are required to manage each platform.

A business selling through five different marketplaces may appear to have an extensive online presence, but if its team is struggling with inventory updates, order fulfilment, customer enquiries and promotional requirements, the additional channels may be creating more operational pressure than commercial value. Expansion should never be measured simply by the number of platforms a business is present on.


The objective is not to be everywhere. It is to be present where it makes commercial and strategic sense.



The Bigger Question: Are You Building Sales or Building a Brand?


This is perhaps the most important consideration of all.


Online marketplaces have made ecommerce more accessible to businesses of almost every size. They have created opportunities for smaller sellers to compete for attention, reach new customers and generate sales without investing heavily in their own digital infrastructure.

For consumers, they have introduced convenience, competitive pricing, flexible payment options and greater access to products from around the world.


There is certainly value in that.


However, businesses need to recognise the difference between generating transactions and developing a brand that customers actively seek out.


A customer who buys a product because it appeared first in a marketplace search may not necessarily remember who sold it.


A customer who purchases because they trust a company's reputation, appreciate its product quality or have developed a positive relationship with the brand has a different reason for choosing that business.


This distinction becomes increasingly important in a marketplace environment where competitors can offer similar products, promotional discounts and delivery arrangements.

If price is the only reason customers purchase from a business, there will almost always be another seller willing to compete on price.


But when customers recognise the value of a brand, businesses have a stronger foundation for developing loyalty and long term relationships. That does not mean marketplace customers cannot become loyal customers. Many businesses have successfully built recognisable brands through marketplace exposure.


It simply means that brand recognition and customer loyalty require deliberate effort, regardless of where the transaction takes place.




My Perspective: Don't Confuse Online Presence With Business Growth


As someone working in marketing, I often see businesses placing considerable emphasis on increasing their visibility across different platforms. There is an understandable belief that the more places a business appears, the greater its chances of generating sales.

And to a certain extent, that makes sense. But I also believe businesses need to be more selective about where they invest their time, money and resources.


Opening another marketplace store should not be treated as an automatic growth strategy, just as launching an ecommerce website should not be considered a guarantee of online success.


Both require planning, management and a clear understanding of consumer behaviour.

For a small business testing its products, marketplaces may provide an accessible starting point.


For an established business with strong brand recognition and a loyal customer base, an independent website may offer greater opportunities for customer retention and brand development.


For others, maintaining both could provide the right balance between reaching new customers and building direct relationships.


There is no single formula that works for every business.


What matters is understanding why a particular platform is being used, what it contributes to the business and whether the benefits justify the investment. We have come a long way from Yahoo Auctions and the early days of online shopping. Today, consumers can purchase almost anything with a few taps on their phones, often with vouchers, rewards and payment options encouraging them to complete their purchases.


The convenience is undeniable, and online marketplaces will continue to influence how businesses sell and how consumers shop. But as businesses become increasingly dependent on these platforms, perhaps it is worth asking one final question.


Are customers choosing your business because they value your brand, or simply because your product happens to be available on their favourite shopping platform?


Because while marketplaces can help businesses make sales today, building a brand that customers remember is what can help sustain the business tomorrow.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page